• Commercial & Business Law

    Commercial & Business Law

    We are first and foremost commercial & business lawyers in Melbourne for people.  Our team will work with you to develop, manage and execute your business plan while ensuring you exploit opportunities, manage risks and achieve commercial success.  

    LEARN MORE
  • Dispute Resolution & Litigation

    Dispute Resolution & Litigation

    We are litigation lawyers in Melbourne specialised in commercial litigation and dispute resolution, we appreciate that resolving a dispute requires more than just following court processes. You can trust Taurus to be in your corner, and fight to deliver results.

     

    LEARN MORE
  • Property & Conveyancing

    Property & Conveyancing

    Enhanced by a wealth of experience, Taurus’ conveyancing lawyers in Melbourne can assist you with all of your conveyancing needs.

    Whether you are selling or purchasing your dream home, we are experienced in handling the conveyance to ensure the smooth settlement of your property.  We successfully perform all steps of your conveyance from reviewing or drafting the Contract of Sale through to confirming settlement has been completed with your real-estate agent.

    We are passionate about providing exemplary personal service to every client and understand that we are here to assist you during one of your most exciting and stressful transactions. We ensure that all of our clients are provided with regular updates and use our own portal allowing clients to login to view the progress of their transaction at any time.

    The conveyancing lawyers at Taurus are registered with PEXA and experts in their field.

    LEARN MORE
  • Intellectual Property

    Intellectual Property

    One of the most valuable assets of any business is its intellectual property. We as intellectual property lawyers Melbourne empower our clients to protect their brand, systems and confidential information by offering them a broad range of legal services related to their IP.

    LEARN MORE
  • Insolvency & Bankruptcy

    Insolvency & Bankruptcy

    We act on behalf of business lawyers, creditors, debtors, and insolvency practitioners in a variety of re-structuring and insolvency matters.

    LEARN MORE
  • Debt Recovery

    Debt Recovery

    We will recover your debts as if they were our own. For many owners, directors, and managers, debt recovery is one of the most confronting and challenging aspects of running a business. It is also crucial to the cash flow of the business, and therefore critical to its financial success.

    LEARN MORE
  • Employment Law

    Employment Law

    We help our clients meet the demands and challenges of managing their workforce.

    We have a team of employment solicitors can assist in any employment law matter ranging from drafting employment agreements to giving termination advice and handling unfair dismissal applications.

    LEARN MORE
ENQUIRE

Public Servant Loses Landmark Free Speech Case in the High Court

When can an employer fire an employee over what they put on social media?  This case gives us some insights into where the Court draws the line.

Facts

Ms Michaela Banerji alleged that her employment with the Department of Immigration and Boarder Protection had been unlawfully terminated in 2013. Ms Banerji claims that her employment ended as a result of Tweets she had sent expressing opinions that were critical of the Australian Government’s immigration policies.

Ms Banerji’s employer argued that an internal investigation had been conducted and found that her Tweets breached the Australian Public Service Code of Conduct. Accordingly, Mr Banerji’s employer terminated her employment.

The Law

There is an implied right in the Constitution that each person is entitled to freedom of political communication. The question in this case was whether the employer’s Code of Conduct breached the implied right contained in the Constitution resulting in Ms Banerji’s termination being unlawful.

The Code of Conduct required:

  1. An employee take reasonable steps to avoid any conflict of interest (real or apparent) in connection with the employee’s employment; and
  2. An employee must uphold the integrity and good reputation of the employee’s agency.

Ms Banerji argued that because the Tweets were sent via her personal device and did not disclose that she was a public service employee, the Tweets did not bring the Government into disrepute.

Decision

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal initially held that Ms Banerji’s termination restricted her implied right to freedom of political communication.

The decision was recently appealed to the High Court who had to determine whether:

  1. The employer’s Code of Conduct was enforceable or a breach of the right to freedom of political information; and
  2. Whether (in light of point 1 above) Ms Banerji’s employment was unlawfully terminated.

The High Court unanimously held that the Code of Conduct was proportionate to its purpose of maintaining an apolitical public service. Given this, the High Court held that Ms Banerji’s employment had been legally terminated and she was not entitled to any compensation as a result.

This case may be relevant for Mr Israel Folau’s Federal Court proceeding which is expected to be heard later this year.

Posted by Taurus Legal Management