• Commercial Law

    Commercial Law

    We are business people as much as we are lawyers. We will take care of the legal documents so you can confidently run your business.
    As your business grows, its risk profile and governance challenges will change. We partner with our clients over the long term to ensure they are in the driver’s seat for success.

  • Dispute Resolution

    Dispute Resolution

    We are in your corner when the going gets tough. Having resolved over 6,500 disputes for business owners have seen it all before.

    Whether you need a skilled negotiator or a fearless litigator, we specialise in delivering commercial results when:

    Customers refuse to pay;
    Suppliers let you down; and
    Business Partners do the wrong thing.

  • Employment & Safety

    Employment & Safety

    The biggest challenge for any business owner, is managing their employees.

    A difficult employee can make you question why you got into business in the first place and be toxic to your team morale.

    We deliver proactive solutions to manage your team via employment contracts, policies and procedures as well as handling employment disputes when they arise.

  • Property & Construction

    Property & Construction

    Property is the key most wealth in Australia.  Whether you are buying, selling, leasing or developing property, you need a lawyer you can count on.

    We can advise on the whole property development process from obtaining finance to development approvals, construction and sale or leasing.

    We also act for the Master Builders Victoria and have extensive expertise in construction contracts and disputes.

  • Family Law

    Family Law

    At Taurus Legal Management we understand the unique challenges clients encounter during family disputes, especially when children are involved. Our family lawyers specialise in handling high-asset cases with a focus on protecting clients wealth, securing their family’s future, and safeguarding the best interests of their children.


Dismissals Held Lawful for Anti-Vaxxer

The Fair Work Commission has just handed down a landmark decision that confirms it is lawful to dismiss an employee who refuses to receive a mandated vaccine.

The mandatory vaccination declaration from the Chief Health Officer only requires employers to refuse access to sites – it does not make dismissals of those employees lawful.  However, this ruling goes much further in supporting employers to enforce mandated vaccinations.

What Does this Decision Mean?

This decision likely means that a dismissal of an employee who does not get a mandated COVID-19 vaccine, will be lawful. There are also a number of cases currently in the New South Wales Supreme Court which are challenging similar issues for the COVID-19 vaccine. These cases will be decided shortly and will provide further guidance.

Reason for Termination

The aged care provider terminated Ms Kimber after she failed and/or refused to receive the Government mandated influenza vaccine. Initially, Ms Kimber produced a letter from a Chinese medicine practitioner which did not meet the requirements of a valid medical exemption. After agreeing to be placed on unpaid leave, Ms Kimber then produced a further letter from a medical practitioner purporting to be a medical exemption. However, the aged care provider and the Commission did not accept it on the basis that:

  1. The letter provided that Ms Kimber had an allergic reaction to her last influenza vaccination. However, it did not appear as though the medical practitioner had treated Ms Kimber at that time;
  2. The only evidence provided of the allergic reaction were undated photographs;
  3. Ms Kimber had never complained of the allergic reaction or taken leave due to the allergic reaction; and
  4. Ms Kimber had also refused to get vaccinated based on her views of its efficacy and side effects.

Basis of the Case

The case was brought as an unfair dismissal, meaning that the dismissal must have been harsh, unjust or unreasonable. This must include an assessment of both the substantive reason for the dismissal and the procedural steps taken to dismiss the employee.

It was found the procedural steps were acceptable given:

  1. The aged care provider provided notice of the mandatory vaccination requirements and made vaccinations readily available;
  2. Ms Kimber was permitted to take a period of unpaid or paid leave;
  3. There were several meetings held with Ms Kimber, including a final meeting prior to her dismissal; and
  4. There was a termination meeting. This was held via telephone as Ms Kimber could not lawfully return to site.

Lawful Reason for Termination

Next, the Commission considered the reason given for the dismissal, which was failing to follow a ‘lawful and reasonable direction.’ The lawful and reasonable direction was failing to comply with the mandatory vaccination order of the NSW Minister for Health.

The Commission was quick to decide that it was a lawful direction as it was enforcing an order of the NSW Minister for Health. The Commission then held that being a law, is inherently reasonable.

This case provides timely guidance, given the latest announcement to increase the industries which are subject to mandatory vaccination. If you would like any advice about the mandatory vaccinations, please contact a member of Taurus Legal Management on (03) 9481 2000 or info@tauruslawyers.com.au.

Posted by Taurus Legal Management